Registered users    
MembershipMembership:
Latest New UserLatest:Mark Ellis
New TodayNew Today:9
New YesterdayNew Yesterday:7
User CountOverall:23403

Private messaging    
You must be logged in to use this module.
Top 10 posters    
NamePosts
Mariette Knap12957
Marina Roos12627
Eriq Neale2117
Stan Guinn1917
Michael Patrick1914
Robert Pearman1786
Nick Pieters1425
william warren641
Stewart Brown620
Kevin D.579
Welcome unauthorized visitor    
If you want to join us in the discussions on this forum you need to register first. Registration is free! If you are already a registered user please login to join the forum.
Small Business Server Support Forum    
Subject: Server Grade vs. Desktop Grade Components
Prev Next
You are not authorized to post a reply.

Author Messages
Chris Cerminara User is Offline
United States
Member since
2/2/2008

Registered Users
Posts: 26

4/03/2008 08:38 PM  
I am in the planning stages of upgrading my server hardware in anticipation of SBS 2008.  I've build quite a few desktop workstation, and I'm very comfortable with desktop components.  What is the advantage of using server-class components over desktop?  My current server is made up of desktop components and it seems to work fine.  I have a Raid 5 set up in case a drive fails, a dual-core Athlon X2, etc.  So what do I really get out of a Xeon processor, "enterprise" hard drives, server motherboards, etc.  Is it reliability, warranty, support?  I relize in the case of MBs, you get multi-CPU capabilities and more RAM, but are they inherently better in terms of quality and stability?
 
I'm looking forward to what people think about this.
Kevin Da Silva User is Offline
Mississauga, Canada
Member since
1/12/2008

Registered Users
Posts: 579

4/04/2008 05:49 PM  
I think that reliability, warranty, support are all the reasons.

Most Vendors offer great support and warranties. If you fry your Motherboard and it takes the CPU and RAM along with it. With a Whitebox Server your out of luck and you have to purchase a new server, reinstall and reconfigure. Whereas a Vendor can have it replace within hours on Warranty.

Also Server class hardware is better engineered to do what it does.

MCSE:Messaging, MCTIP, SBS Specialist
Brian Mayo User is Offline
Along the shoreline of New England
Member since
6/22/2005

Registered Users
Posts: 317

8/05/2008 01:26 PM  
Server grade hardware is generally certified to have full Windows Server support, main point being drivers, mature, stable drivers.
 
Server grade hardware usually comes with a longer warranty (except the el cheapo entry level models).  Generally most mid-range and on up models will have a 3 year warranty. 
 
Hardware on these models is designed to last longer, more robust, better quality and engineering.  For example...lets take a look at the hard drives.  Except for the el cheapo entry level models, you'll generally find servers have hard drives with at least 600,000 MTBF hours (there's that 3 year thing again)..many have enterprise grade drives which have over 1 million hours MTBF (that's a 5 year drive).  Desktop PCs, most of them, usually just have 1 year drives or 3 year drives on the better models.
william warren User is Offline
United States
Member since
12/8/2005

Registered Users
Posts: 641

9/06/2008 06:53 PM  
Server quality components are factory certified for 24/7 operation at maximum utilization. Server grade components also have ECC in various stages of the pipeline to protect against data corruptions. That and the highly stable, long-term nature of driver support plus manufacturer warranties all push server grade components above desktop components.

Registered Microsoft Partner
Alex Sluiter User is Offline
United States
Member since
1/26/2007

Registered Users
Posts: 40

11/26/2008 04:55 PM  
It's the same idea as all aspects of life...you get what you pay for (most of the time). Think of it from a cost standpoint. It may cost you (or your client for that matter) $1000 to make the move from desktop to server grade components. If the server goes down do to hardware failure, you/your client may loose $500, or $500,000. Also, when servers go down, people are getting paid to do nothing but sit and wait. It may happen once or it may happen 3 times throughout the life of the server. The fact is, downtime costs money. Spending an extra $1000 now, may save you from missing a quote, or save you from paying people to sit around and wait for new server components. This doesn't even take into account what was previously stated regarding warranty and replacement response times.
You are not authorized to post a reply.



ActiveForums 3.7
Forum policy    
These Discussion Forums are dedicated to the discussion of the Small Business Server and related server and client software. For the benefit of the community please observe the following posting guidelines:
  1. No Advertising. This includes promotion of commercial products and non-commercial products which are not directly related to Small Business Server and related server and client software.
  2. No Flaming or Trolling.
  3. No Profanity, Racism, or Prejudice.
  4. Site Moderators have the final word on approving/removing a thread or post or comment.