Registered users    
MembershipMembership:
Latest New UserLatest:Mark Ellis
New TodayNew Today:9
New YesterdayNew Yesterday:7
User CountOverall:23403

Private messaging    
You must be logged in to use this module.
Top 10 posters    
NamePosts
Mariette Knap12959
Marina Roos12627
Eriq Neale2117
Stan Guinn1917
Michael Patrick1914
Robert Pearman1786
Nick Pieters1425
william warren642
Stewart Brown620
Kevin D.579
Welcome unauthorized visitor    
If you want to join us in the discussions on this forum you need to register first. Registration is free! If you are already a registered user please login to join the forum.
Small Business Server Support Forum    
Subject: OneCare for server any good?
Prev Next
You are not authorized to post a reply.

Author Messages
Kieran Mann User is Offline
United Kingdom
Member since
1/15/2007

Registered Users
Posts: 95

8/31/2008 10:29 PM  
Hi, was wondering how OneCare for Server detection rate compares to the likes of AVG E-mail Server Edition for example. I heard bad reviews of OneCare but i've also heard that its improved recently. I would like to use OneCare on the server and clients as it integrates nicely with the SBS console thus saving the hastle of working with multipul programs from different vendors. I've used AVG in the past and it flags up around 10 viruses a week on a 5 user setup.
 
Kieran.
thomas de smet User is Offline
Belgium
Member since
1/31/2006

Platinum Membership
Posts: 119

10/23/2008 09:12 AM  
same question here ... .
We are using Trendmicro for quite a long time now, but recently we had some bad virus experiences due to trnemicro, see also this blog post:
So I am really pissed that a virus could get through on 5 client pc's ... .
I've also had some bad experience on the anti-spam feature of TM, so I am thinking of doing a switch.
 
With SBS 2008 Onecare and Forefront is included (trial off course), so why do we need a 3rd party after all (man this looks alot like windows media player included in win xp :p)?
Do I still need to look for a 3rd party application, which is not integrated in the SBS console?
 
Are Onecare and forefront good enough, performant? anybody with experience on the 2 MS software packets??
Mariette Knap User is Online
The Netherlands
Member since
3/24/2005

Forum Admins
Posts: 12959

10/23/2008 09:57 AM  
After many years I will leave Trend. Either I will use MS stuff or use Sophos...not decided yet.

Mariëtte Knap Smallbizserver.Net AdministratorMission accomplished. We have joined the branch office to our SBS 2003 Headquarters and have the same user experience on the branch office as we have on our local  network at the Headquarters. Want to know how? Signup up for a subscription and get instant access to the article series 'How to add an additional Domain Controller from a remote office to the SBS domain'
Marshall Lai User is Offline
Hong Kong
Member since
3/27/2005

Platinum Membership
Posts: 133

10/31/2008 12:30 PM  
MS does not have a good track record with viruses on their OSes so why trust them now for their virus protection product?  Especially when not many reputable sites rank them highly....
 
For me cheap, reliable, and centralized AVG works just fine........
Will Smith User is Offline
United States
Member since
4/9/2007

Platinum Membership
Posts: 53

10/31/2008 03:26 PM  
My experience with Windows Live OneCare has been excellent -- as a network administrator and a consumer.

The Onecare product itself is much more than simply an anti-virus/anti-spyware; it offers easy yet comprehensive centralized backup, monitoring of numerous security settings, and automated performance optimization tools.

The Server edition not only extends OneCare's powerful internet security features to protect your server, it also provides you with the ability to monitor your desktops and notebooks in a centralized manner.

From my subjective tests, OneCare appears to consume less system resources than the other "tier one" products I've previously used. My users like it, too, because it is less intrusive on their computing experience.

Updates can be performed thru WSUS, further giving you confidence the product is up-to-date on your client machines. And unless I am mistaken, OneCare features the same AV machinery and databases as ForeFront Client Security, Microsoft's solution that is popular in the enterprise market.

Ocassionally I will run online AV tools from several major vendors to see what, if anything, OneCare may have missed. I have never seen anything on the server that has caused any concern, perhaps due to the fact I am not carelessly browsing the internet with it. On the client machines, the only instances where other AV scanning products detect anything is in the case of a few low-priority tracking cookies.

My advice is: see for yourself and make up your own mind.
Sergio Ricci User is Offline
United Kingdom
Member since
5/4/2007

Platinum Membership
Posts: 17

11/01/2008 02:43 PM  
I can't comment on OneCare or Trend but if it's of any help I can recommend Sophos.

I move to Sophos from Symantec earlier this year and have been very happy with it. I find it easy to manage and picked up some viruses and malware that Symantec appeared to have let through to the message store. It's relatively light on resources compared to Symantec and the combination of Sophos' Spam filter together with Exchanges Intelligent Message Filter (correctly configured) means that very few spam messages get through. Oh and Sophos have 24/7 support as standard (it was extra with Symantec). Useful if you encounter a problem out side of business hours which, if you carry out any maintenance, tasks etc out of hours and come across a problem, can be a god sent.

Sophos offer a 30 days trial so you could do worse that give it a try before parting with good cash.

Sergio
Rene Leussink User is Offline
Deventer, Netherlands
Member since
6/5/2005

Platinum Membership
Posts: 63

11/11/2008 07:23 AM  
I'm loving ESET NOD32 Antivirus for SBS. I like it so much I became a reseller for the product.
See the track record for yourself: http://nod32.nl/docs/avcomparitive_summary2007.pdf
 
It's one of the best antivirus products for proactive on demand detection with a very low footprint, so even the somewhat older machines keep performing well after installing.
It has got a management console you can install on the SBS server for pushing the installation software to the clients and monitoring the status of the workstations. With the SBS version of the product you get a management server, exchange virus protection and not always up to date 'virus signatures' but also the new software. When configured correctly (which by the way isn't very hard) it also keeps the anti-virus software current. The other products I know of only update their 'virus signatures' and not their software. ESET/NOD32 constantly updates their software also and it's automatically downloaded and installed on the server and clients.
I'm using the product for over 3 years now and am a very happy user
 
By the way... it has a very competitive price and it's possible to add client licenses for the same price during the licensing period (let me explain: if you bought the license for 3 years for 15 client you're bount to have more than 15 clients over this period. With nod32 you can add the license of additional client to the existing license for the price of the remainder period. So say after one year you add a client pc you only have to pay for the remainder of 2 years for this one client).
 
So all in all a complete, easy to manage and fast anti-virus solution.
 
Kind Regards,

ReusSoft - SBS oplossingen van de SBS partner voor het MKB.
You are not authorized to post a reply.



ActiveForums 3.7
Forum policy    
These Discussion Forums are dedicated to the discussion of the Small Business Server and related server and client software. For the benefit of the community please observe the following posting guidelines:
  1. No Advertising. This includes promotion of commercial products and non-commercial products which are not directly related to Small Business Server and related server and client software.
  2. No Flaming or Trolling.
  3. No Profanity, Racism, or Prejudice.
  4. Site Moderators have the final word on approving/removing a thread or post or comment.